What Is a Proxy Statement (DEF 14A)? Executive Pay and Shareholder Votes

A proxy statement is the document a US public company files on SEC Schedule 14A and sends to shareholders before a meeting, listing every matter up for a vote.

Executive pay, board nominees, the auditor, and who owns large blocks of stock all live in the proxy, not the annual report. This page covers what a DEF 14A contains, how to read the pay tables, and how it connects to the 10-K. It is descriptive throughout.

Schedule 14A and the DEF 14A label

Schedule 14A is the SEC form titled "Information required in proxy statement," filed under Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. A proxy is the authority to vote someone else's shares, and asking for it triggers this disclosure.

The codes come from EDGAR. PRE 14A is a preliminary proxy statement not related to a contested matter or merger. DEF 14A is the definitive version, the one sent to shareholders. DEFA14A is definitive additional soliciting material.

Most routine annual meetings never produce a PRE 14A. Rule 14a-6 requires the preliminary version at least 10 calendar days before definitive copies are first sent to shareholders, but exempts meetings whose only business is electing directors, ratifying accountants, a Rule 14a-8 proposal, a shareholder nominee, or approving a compensation plan. Definitive copies must be filed no later than the day they are first sent.

What is on the ballot

Schedule 14A is a numbered list, and a company answers only the items its meeting triggers. Item 7, directors and executive officers, applies when directors are elected and pulls in Regulation S-K Item 407, where director independence and audit committee composition live. Item 8 pulls in Item 402, the pay disclosures. Item 9 covers the independent public accountants, whose ratification is a standard annual vote. Item 21 requires the vote needed for each matter other than the approval of auditors. Item 24 is the say-on-pay item.

Outside proposals arrive through Rule 14a-8. A proponent must have continuously held $2,000 of voting stock for three years, $15,000 for two years, or $25,000 for one year, may submit one proposal per meeting capped at 500 words, and must get it to the company at least 120 calendar days before the prior year's proxy release date.

Reading the pay disclosures

Regulation S-K Item 402 does the work. Four pieces matter.

Compensation Discussion and Analysis, Item 402(b). Company narrative against a required checklist: the program's objectives, what it rewards, each element of pay, and how amounts are set.

Summary Compensation Table, Item 402(c). Three completed fiscal years per named executive officer in fixed columns: salary, bonus, stock awards, option awards, non-equity incentive pay, pension and deferred compensation change, all other compensation, total. Named executive officers are the principal executive and financial officers plus the three next most highly compensated. The stock awards column is the one people misread: Item 402(c) requires the aggregate grant date fair value under FASB ASC Topic 718, an accounting estimate struck on the grant date, not money received.

Pay versus performance, Item 402(v). Added in 2022 under Exchange Act Section 14(i), from Dodd-Frank Section 953(a). It puts the table total for the principal executive officer beside a differently calculated "executive compensation actually paid," with total shareholder return, peer group return, net income, and a company-selected measure.

CEO pay ratio, Item 402(u). From Dodd-Frank Section 953(b): the median annual total compensation of employees other than the principal executive officer, that officer's total, and the ratio.

Granted and realized pay are separate: Item 402(f) shows equity still held, Item 402(g) what vested or was exercised. On sales the proxy is silent. That is what Form 4 filings cover, filed under Exchange Act Section 16(a) by directors, officers and 10% owners within two business days of a transaction. Kresmion tracks Form 4 insider activity and groups it into clusters.

The beneficial ownership tables

Schedule 14A Item 6(d) pulls Regulation S-K Item 403 into the proxy, and it produces two tables. The first lists any person or group known to the company to beneficially own more than five percent of a class of voting securities, with name, address, amount and percent of class. The second lists management: every director and nominee by name, each named executive officer, and all directors and officers as a group, with a footnote flagging shares pledged as security. Both count ownership under Rule 13d-3, which includes shares acquirable within 60 days.

The five percent list overlaps with what those holders file themselves. A large passive holder files a Schedule 13G; an investor with intent to influence control files a Schedule 13D. Institutional managers report US-listed positions quarterly on Form 13F. The proxy table is a snapshot as of a record date the company picks, so compare as-of dates.

How the proxy and the 10-K fit together

Form 10-K Part III covers directors and governance (Item 10), executive compensation (Item 11), security ownership (Item 12), related transactions and director independence (Item 13), and accountant fees (Item 14). In most 10-Ks that is a page of cross-references: General Instruction G(3) permits Part III to be incorporated by reference from the definitive proxy, provided the proxy is filed not later than 120 days after fiscal year end. Miss that window and Part III must go into the 10-K itself or an amendment.

Advisory votes and binding votes

Rule 14a-21 requires, at a meeting where directors are elected, a separate resolution subject to shareholder advisory vote on named executive officer compensation, no later than the meeting held in the third calendar year after the previous such vote. It was adopted in 2011 under Dodd-Frank Section 951, and emerging growth companies are excluded.

Advisory means the tally compels nothing. The SEC's investor bulletin says "The Say-on-Pay, frequency, and golden parachute votes are advisory rather than binding," and that Dodd-Frank specifies the vote "shall not be binding on the issuer or the board of directors of an issuer."

Shareholders separately vote on frequency: once a year, once every two years, once every three years, or abstain. Whether any other ballot item binds comes from state corporate law and the company's bylaws rather than the proxy rules, and Item 21 makes the company state the vote required for each matter other than approval of auditors.

Key takeaways

Frequently asked questions

When is the proxy filed relative to the annual meeting and the 10-K?

The definitive proxy must be filed no later than the day it is first sent to shareholders, ahead of the meeting. Timing is also tied to the 10-K: to incorporate Part III by reference, the proxy must be filed within 120 days after fiscal year end.

Is the say-on-pay vote binding?

No. The SEC's investor bulletin says say-on-pay, frequency and golden parachute votes are advisory rather than binding, and Dodd-Frank specifies the vote shall not be binding on the issuer or its board. The rules require disclosure instead: under Item 402(b) the company must state whether and how it considered the most recent result.

What is the difference between the proxy statement and the 10-K?

The 10-K is the annual report on the business and financial statements. The proxy is built around a shareholder meeting: nominees, ballot items, executive pay and share ownership. They are stitched together, since Part III of the 10-K is usually incorporated by reference from the proxy.

Where do I see what executives were paid versus what they actually sold?

The Summary Compensation Table reports pay as granted, with equity at grant date fair value under FASB ASC Topic 718. Vesting and exercises appear in the option exercises and stock vested table. Sales do not appear in the proxy at all: they go on Form 4, filed under Section 16(a) by directors, officers and 10% owners within two business days of the transaction.

This page is information, not investment advice.

---

Source: SEC Schedule 14A, 17 CFR 240.14a-101 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/chapter-II/part-240/section-240.14a-101); Rule 14a-6 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/section-240.14a-6), Rule 14a-8 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/section-240.14a-8), Rule 14a-21 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/section-240.14a-21), Rule 16a-3 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/section-240.16a-3); Regulation S-K Item 402 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/section-229.402) and Item 403 (https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/section-229.403); SEC Form 10-K (https://www.sec.gov/files/form10-k.pdf); SEC Form 4 (https://www.sec.gov/files/form4.pdf); SEC Investor Bulletin on Say-on-Pay (https://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/sayonpay.pdf); SEC Pay Versus Performance guide (https://www.sec.gov/resources-small-businesses/small-business-compliance-guides/pay-versus-performance); SEC Pay Ratio Disclosure (https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/final/2015/33-9877.pdf); EDGAR Filer Manual Vol. II (https://www.sec.gov/info/edgar/forms/edgform.pdf).

Kresmion Research.